Silver Lining Logo Focus Group

How to Encrypt an Email (Without Losing Your Mind): A Complete Guide to Secure Email Communication

Published on:
Published in:
Author
22 April 2025
admin
Back to Resources

Have you ever sent an email and then instantly thought, "Should I have encrypted that?" You're not alone. This common moment of digital anxiety is one many professionals experience - often after it's too late to do anything about it.

Whether you're handling customer data, financial information, contracts, or simply value privacy in your communications, knowing how to properly encrypt emails is an essential skill in today's digital landscape. This comprehensive guide will walk you through everything you need to know about email encryption, from basic concepts to practical implementation across various platforms.

What Email Encryption Actually Means: Understanding How Email Encryption Works

Email encryption transforms your message into secure, encoded content that only the intended recipient can decode and read. But what's actually happening behind the scenes?

According to the National Cyber Security Centre, this method uses complex mathematical algorithms to convert your message into unreadable code during transmission. When implemented correctly, even if unauthorised parties intercept the message, the contents remain indecipherable without the proper decryption keys.

It's important to understand that this doesn't hide the fact that you've sent an email - metadata like sender address, recipient, subject line, and timestamp typically remain visible. What it does is it protects the actual content of your communication, including:

  • The body text of your message
  • Any attachments you've included
  • Links contained within the message
  • Signatures and other embedded content

For professionals handling sensitive information such as client data, financial details, contracts, or personal information, the UK Information Commissioner's Office recommends encryption as a standard security practice rather than an optional precaution.

Why is Email Encryption Important?

The necessity for email encryption has grown exponentially in recent years, driven by several converging factors:

Rising Cybersecurity Threats

Email remains the most vulnerable communication channel for most organisations. According to the 2023 Verizon Data Breach Investigations Report, email-based attacks account for approximately 74% of all breaches, with business email compromise (BEC) and phishing leading the way. Using email encryption or a secure email service provides a critical layer of defense against these threats.

Regulatory Requirements

The regulatory landscape has shifted dramatically toward mandatory protection of sensitive information:

  • GDPR requires organisations to implement "appropriate technical and organisational measures" to protect personal data, with encryption mentioned explicitly as a recommended measure
  • The UK Data Protection Act 2018 maintains similar requirements post-Brexit
  • Industry-specific regulations like PCI DSS for payment processing and HIPAA for healthcare impose strict encryption requirements

Failure to comply with these regulations can result in significant financial penalties. In 2023, the ICO issued over £42 million in fines, with a substantial portion related to insufficient data protection measures.

Financial Consequences of Data Breaches

Beyond regulatory fines, the financial impact of data breaches continues to rise. IBM's Cost of a Data Breach Report found that the average cost of a data breach in the UK reached £3.7 million in 2023, with unencrypted data significantly increasing this figure. Email encryption represents a relatively low-cost preventative measure against these potential losses.

Reputational Damage

Perhaps most devastating is the long-term reputational damage that can result from exposing sensitive client or customer information. According to Deloitte's research, 87% of executives rate reputation risk as more important than other strategic risks, with data breaches among the top reputation-damaging events.

How to Encrypt Emails in Popular Platforms

The implementation of email encryption varies across platforms. Here's how to enable it in the most commonly used email services:

Microsoft Outlook (Desktop and Microsoft 365)

Microsoft 365 users benefit from built-in encryption capabilities through Microsoft Purview Message Encryption (formerly Office 365 Message Encryption):

  1. Open a new email message
  2. Navigate to the Options tab in the ribbon
  3. Click on Encrypt
  4. Select your preferred encryption level:
    • Encrypt Only: Encrypts the message, but recipients can forward it
    • Do Not Forward: Prevents recipients from forwarding, printing, or copying content

Microsoft 365 Business Premium, E3, or E5 plans include comprehensive encryption tools. For detailed configuration instructions, see Microsoft's official documentation.

Advanced Options: For organisations requiring heightened security, S/MIME encryption can be implemented with:

  • Digital certificates for each user
  • Exchange Online configuration changes
  • Certificate distribution management

Encryption in Gmail (Google Workspace)

Gmail implements Transport Layer Security (TLS) encryption by default, providing protection when both sender and recipient email servers support TLS. For enhanced security, Google Workspace offers additional options:

Basic Confidential Mode

  1. When composing a message, click the confidentiality mode icon (lock) at the bottom
  2. Set an expiration date and optional passcode
  3. Recipients will be unable to forward, copy, print, or download the message

S/MIME Encryption (Enhanced Security)

  1. Requires Google Workspace Enterprise or Education edition
  2. The administrator must enable S/MIME functionality
  3. Digital certificates must be issued and managed
  4. When composing, the encryption status appears as a colored lock icon

For complete implementation details, consult Google's security documentation.

Apple Mail

Apple's Mail app supports S/MIME encryption across macOS and iOS:

  1. Obtain an encryption certificate from a trusted provider
  2. Import the certificate into your device's keychain
  3. Enable S/MIME in Mail settings
  4. When composing, click the encryption icon to secure your message

The Apple Platform Security Guide provides detailed information on implementing S/MIME across Apple devices.

Common Email Encryption Mistakes to Avoid When Sending Emails

False Security Assumptions

Many users incorrectly assume their emails are automatically encrypted or that basic TLS provides complete protection. Research from Stanford University shows that approximately 62% of users overestimate their email security level.

Plain Text Password Transmission in Unencrypted Email

Despite widespread warnings, LastPass research found that 67% of professionals still send passwords and access credentials via unencrypted email at least occasionally, putting sensitive information at risk when different email providers, such as Gmail and Outlook, may not automatically encrypt the connection.

Certificate Management Failures

Digital certificates require proper management, including renewal and verification. The Sectigo Certificate Management Survey revealed that 71% of organisations experienced at least one certificate-related outage in 2023, often due to expired certificates.

Attachment Oversight

While message bodies might be encrypted, users frequently forget that attachments require separate protection. Egress Software found that 79% of organisations had experienced data breaches through improperly secured email attachments.

Implementation Barriers

Many organisations delay encryption implementation due to perceived complexity. Forrester Research indicates that this perception gap leads to an average delay of 7.8 months between recognising the need for encryption and actual deployment.

Secure Email Checklist: How to Encrypt All Messages

The Information Commissioner's Office and National Cyber Security Centre recommend verifying these elements before sending sensitive communications:

Pre-Send Security Verification for New Email

  • Encryption Status: Confirm the message will be transmitted with appropriate encryption by checking message options
  • Attachment Protection: Verify that all attachments are properly secured when sending an encrypted email
  • Recipient Verification: Double-check that all recipients are correct and appropriate for your email service provider
  • Sensitive Content Assessment: Evaluate if the message contents require encryption or if you should sign or encrypt
  • Access Control Configuration: Set appropriate "encrypt or do not forward" restrictions, expiration dates, and other controls for your mail account

Organisational Best Practices

  • Classification System: Implement a data classification system that clearly identifies what information requires encryption
  • Policy Documentation: Create and communicate clear guidelines for when encryption must be used
  • Training Program: Establish regular training to ensure all users understand encryption procedures
  • Audit Mechanisms: Implement monitoring to verify encryption usage compliance
  • Incident Response Plan: Develop procedures for addressing potential breaches of unencrypted communications

Mobile Email Encryption: Encrypting Messages on Your Phone

As mobile devices become primary email access points for many professionals, ensuring encryption extends to mobile platforms is essential:

Platform-Specific Implementation

Outlook Mobile App

  • Access encryption options via the three-dot menu when composing
  • Supports Microsoft Purview Message Encryption features
  • Requires Microsoft 365 subscription with appropriate licensing
  • Microsoft mobility documentation provides configuration details

Gmail Mobile App and Outlook

  • Basic TLS encryption is applied automatically when available for email providers like Gmail and Outlook
  • Confidential mode is accessible through the three-dot menu to select encryption options
  • S/MIME requires enterprise implementation and appears as a lock icon when an email is encrypted
  • Google Workspace mobile security guide offers implementation instructions for encrypting in Gmail
  • Microsoft support documentation explains how to read the encrypted message you receive on mobile devices

Specialised Secure Email Apps

  • ProtonMail, Tutanota, and other security-focused providers offer dedicated mobile apps
  • These typically provide end-to-end encryption by default
  • Often includes additional security features like PIN access and biometric authentication

A SANS Institute study found that mobile email security often lags behind desktop implementations, making platform-specific knowledge crucial for comprehensive protection.

Frequently Asked Questions About Email Encryption

Can I encrypt emails sent to recipients using different email providers like Gmail and Outlook?

Yes, though implementation varies by method. TLS encryption works between supporting email servers regardless of provider. Many third-party email apps and services now support encryption between different providers like Gmail and Yahoo Mail accounts. For end-to-end email encryption:

  • S/MIME requires certificate exchange between the sender and the recipient
  • PGP requires key exchange and compatible software on both ends
  • Solutions like Virtru and ProtonMail can manage cross-platform requirements through web portals for recipients

Does email encryption ensure GDPR compliance for sending emails?

While encryption contributes significantly to compliance, the UK Information Commissioner's Office emphasises it's one component of a comprehensive data protection strategy. Email is protected when encrypted, but simply using encryption doesn't guarantee that your organisation is fully compliant. GDPR Article 32 mentions encryption explicitly as an "appropriate technical measure," but compliance requires additional controls around data access, processing, retention, and subject rights when handling inbound and outbound email.

Can I retroactively encrypt previously sent emails or automatically encrypt all messages?

No, encryption must be applied before transmission, as the National Cyber Security Centre explains. Once an email has been sent unencrypted, it should be considered permanently unprotected. While you can set up your system to automatically encrypt all outgoing messages and encrypt all future communications, you cannot decrypt the email after sending it unprotected. The only exception would be if you have administrative access to both the sending and receiving mail servers and could delete the message before it's read—a scenario rarely possible in practice.

Is email encryption equivalent to VPN protection?

No. These technologies serve different purposes:

  • Email encryption protects specific message content during transmission and storage
  • VPN services encrypt all internet traffic and mask your IP address/location

According to cybersecurity experts at CSO Online, both technologies may be necessary depending on your security requirements - VPNs for general browsing privacy and email encryption for specific sensitive communications.

Does encryption impact email delivery speed?

The Internet Engineering Task Force standards indicate that modern encryption implementations have a negligible performance impact on standard communications. Most users will not notice any delivery delay with contemporary encryption methods. In rare cases involving very large attachments or older systems, minimal delays might occur.

Conclusion: Is Email Encryption a Good Idea?

Email encryption provides essential protection for sensitive information from sender to recipient throughout its journey. With cyberattacks increasing in frequency and sophistication, and data protection regulations imposing stricter requirements, implementing proper encryption isn't just good practice—it's becoming essential for business continuity, regulatory compliance, and reputational protection. For most organisations, the ability to encrypt email content and send encrypted email via supported email services is not just a good idea—it's increasingly becoming a necessity.

Whether you're a financial advisor sending client documents, a healthcare provider sharing patient information, or simply a professional handling confidential business data, encrypted email ensures your communications remain private and secure from unauthorised access.

The good news is that encryption technology has evolved significantly, making implementation more accessible and user-friendly than ever before. Many 365 subscriptions include advanced email encryption features, and public key encryption methods are now easier to implement when you want to encrypt an email. By understanding your options and following best practices, you can choose to either encrypt communications or leave them unencrypted based on content sensitivity, all without unnecessary complexity or the need for different email service apps.

For personalised assistance with your email encryption needs, contact our security team for a consultation tailored to your specific requirements.

Share on:

Latests news & insights

Take a look at the latest news, insights, materials & content from our resource centre
22 April 2025

How to Encrypt an Email (Without Losing Your Mind): A Complete Guide to Secure Email Communication

Have you ever sent an email and then instantly thought, "Should I have encrypted that?" You're not alone
Learn More
1 2 3 142
Silver Lining Logo Focus Group
© Silver Lining Convergence Ltd
Registered Company Number: 06212357
linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram